Welcome to this week’s news round up. It’s a bumper edition with lots of important notices, so please read carefully!!
As we will be running meetings via Zoom in January & February 2022, it was decided that it was not practical to run the scheduled print competitions. In their place will be 2 additional PDI competitions on a set subject. It was agreed these would be Landscape/Architecture and Abstract/Experimental, as these topics linked in with the desire expressed in the club survey for more opportunities for creativity and diversity of genres.
So the revised competition program is:
January 21st will be a set subject.
Div 2: Landscape and architecture: 2 images per person either both in one category or one of each
Div 1: Abstract or experimental: 2 images per person, either both in one category or one of each.
The competition would be judged as a single comp ie: Div 2 there would be … commended, highly commended, 3rd, 2nd, 1st …judging both landscape and architecture together. Similarly Div 1.
February 7th will remain as per original programme (Set subjects as set out in the programme)
February 14th will be the reverse of Jan 21st
Div 2: Abstract and experimental
Div 1: Landscape and architecture
March 14th: PDI round 4
March 21st: A one-off print competition with a possible non-score appraisal (this needs to be agreed by committee)
May 9th : this will be a print competition of sorts, more details to follow.
2. Our results this week in SCPF League 1
In one week in the Southern Counties Photographic Federation League 1 competition we have come top and bottom of the eight clubs competing and currently appear to be joint fifth; See table attached.
3. Chance to watch the SxPF PDI Championship Sat 4th Dec
The Sussex Photographic Federation organises this annual PDI competition between about 20 Sussex clubs. It is an opportunity to view their best images and the judges commentary. If you would like to watch it, register your interest with the SxPF Secretary, Valerie Mcmanus
valmcmanusuk@yahoo.com before Thurs 2nd Dec. Register soon as they already have 40 registered out of the 100 maximum places.
4. Judging in our PDI competitions recently
There has been some consternation amongst members who have taken part in our PDI competitions recently about the low scores awarded to some images, even when they had received a favourable critique. In response to this, Ken Scott has posted the following on Facebook:
“Last year I presented and explained in detail the SCPF scoring guidance to our club and we agreed to adopt it.
I’m aware that not all judges understand it or apply it consistently well, but it is, in my view, the best scheme. We are developing a quick reference card and I’ll also relink the guide paper
https://southerncountiespf.org.uk/…/2020-SCPF-Judging… Bear in mind that not all judges are SCPF, so guidance from other Federations may vary.
To be concise for now – the scores are a ranking, broadly separated into four bands: below average (for this event), average (which may have nothing wrong and be of a reasonable to good standard), very good, and outstanding. All relative to this competition.
Marking on an absolute scale has some merit on the surface but would be impossible to implement (too long to discuss here).
I encourage club photographers to understand this, so I explain it at the start of my judging evening: “there will be many images in the low to mid ranges tonight that having nothing wrong with them; they are perfectly OK but maybe not as impacting or expressive as those that score highly.”
Sometimes, provided the feedback is given in the right way, we have to just accept that an image will score low – the judge maybe ‘just doesn’t get it’ or it fails to move them.
Making 12 ‘the new 14’ has given us greater scope to separate the middle ranges and has proved to be very successful.
We should not go looking for ‘faults’ to justify a lower mark. Even an image scoring 12 may have none in a high standard of competition. In a Div 1 league match, all 64 images are very good by club standards. They have to be separated by their expressive quality, which is subjective and explains the variances in marks between judges.
Our judges have been reminded again and again to manage expectations and to make sure the mark fits the comment. If judges are not understanding or applying the guidance then the club must a) ensure that we brief them better (leave that with me), and b) provide me with the official SCPF feedback.
But the bottom line is that if marks really aren’t working, we as a club should stop asking our judges to award them. In the recent survey a majority still believe they are important.
I’m ok with the banter of assigning a nickname within those receiving a low score – cricket does it all the time with ‘ducks’. But please be aware that this is a serious piece of work for me and my judging team to attempt to harmonise both judging practice and club expectations. So if you do have any questions about judging, please do ask me; I’m here and available and always willing …””